What are your thoughts on A Knight's Tale?

Its one of those movies I just can't NOT love. But it seems to draw a lot of lines in the sand for people. When I talk to non-industry people the majority seem to enjoy it, but when I speak to people who work in the film industry or just teach film classes they seem to hate it, specifically for the anachronism.

What do you guys think? Was it done well? Does it hold up?